← Rare Finds  ·  Croton Pond, Newaygo
Rare Find of the Week · November 2026

A knotty pine cabin on Croton Pond.

$285,000 Available 5539 Front Street, Newaygo, MI 49337 · Croton Pond · Newaygo County
Why this one is rare

Knotty pine, a new walkway, and a dock.

This is a 1940 cabin with 50 feet of frontage on Croton Pond, the stretch of the Muskegon River above Croton Dam. It's one bedroom and one bath in about 900 square feet, with knotty pine on nearly every wall and a pass-through bar into the kitchen.

The water work is done. The shoreline was recently reinforced, there's a new walkway down to the water, and the dock is included. The seller also made electrical improvements, added insulation, and put newer roofs on both the cabin and the storage building.

There's no association, and the Dragon Trail, local restaurants and parks are minutes away, so it works as a getaway for paddling, fishing and riding as much as for boating.

People are one of two things: fine or thriving. If a cabin you can lock up and leave sounds like thriving, take a look.

$285K
List price, down from $315K
50 ft
Of frontage on Croton Pond, with a dock
1 / 1
Bedroom and bath
898
Sq ft of knotty pine
1940
Year built
None
Association
Muskegon River Dock included New shoreline work Newer roofs Near the Dragon Trail

The honest part

This is a one-bedroom cabin heated by a gas space heater and cooled with window units, so it's a getaway more than a full-time home as it sits. The sellers have never lived there, so their disclosure is mostly blank, and that makes the inspection more important than usual. It has been on the market about five months with one price drop, and that history is useful to know going into a negotiation.

Thinking of renting it out?

The City of Newaygo licenses short-term rentals, but this cabin sits in Croton Township, and the township's posted zoning ordinance (last amended in 2014) doesn't appear to address them. I'll confirm with the township before anyone counts on rental income.

Where it is

Getting there: Croton Pond is just outside Newaygo, about 45 minutes north of Grand Rapids.

Running the numbers

What it might actually cost to own.

At about 7.18% on a 30-year fixed (Freddie Mac's average as of November 5, 2026), principal and interest on $285,000 comes to roughly $1,830 a month with 5% down, $1,740 with 10% down, and $1,540 with 20% down. Property tax and insurance come on top of that. Second-home loans often carry a higher rate and a bigger down payment, so ask a lender about your situation.

After a sale, taxable value resets to the SEV, which is $88,500 for 2025. Using Michigan's Property Tax Estimator (Department of Treasury, 2025 millage rates) for Croton Township and Newaygo Public Schools, that comes to about $4,250 a year as a second home (48.00 mills, about $355 a month) or about $2,670 as a full-time home with the principal residence exemption (30.19 mills). The seller's listed tax figure is $1,732, which is lower than either estimate, so ask the township for the full year's bills.

About these numbers

Payment figures are estimates for illustration only, not a loan offer or a guarantee of terms. They assume roughly a 7.18% 30-year fixed rate (Freddie Mac's average as of November 5, 2026; rates change daily) and the down payments noted; your actual rate, payment, taxes, and insurance will differ based on your lender, your credit, and the assessor's valuation after sale. Tax estimates use the State of Michigan Property Tax Estimator with 2025 millage rates and the most recent SEV on record. Property taxes reset on transfer under Michigan law, and a non-homestead second home is taxed higher than a principal residence. Short-term-rental income is not guaranteed and depends on township, county and state rules. I am a REALTOR, not a lender, attorney, or tax advisor, so please verify all figures with the right professional. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Equal Housing Opportunity.

THRIVE

Everything I know is right here. Want to go see it?

No gate, no "DM me for the real story." It's all on this page. If it's pulling at you, email me and I'll set up a showing and walk through the actual ownership costs with you. No pressure either way. If the timing's off, I'll tell you.

Featured find. 5539 Front Street, Newaygo, MI 49337 is listed by Daniel Mehney, Greenridge Realty (616-446-9161). Photos by Dan Mehney. I'm featuring it here because it's a genuinely rare one, and I'm glad to represent you on it as your buyer's agent. All information is from the listing and deemed reliable but not guaranteed; verify all details independently. Equal Housing Opportunity.