At about 7.18% on a 30-year fixed (Freddie Mac's average as of November 5, 2026), principal and interest on $285,000 comes to roughly $1,830 a month with 5% down, $1,740 with 10% down, and $1,540 with 20% down. Property tax and insurance come on top of that. Second-home loans often carry a higher rate and a bigger down payment, so ask a lender about your situation.
After a sale, taxable value resets to the SEV, which is $88,500 for 2025. Using Michigan's Property Tax Estimator (Department of Treasury, 2025 millage rates) for Croton Township and Newaygo Public Schools, that comes to about $4,250 a year as a second home (48.00 mills, about $355 a month) or about $2,670 as a full-time home with the principal residence exemption (30.19 mills). The seller's listed tax figure is $1,732, which is lower than either estimate, so ask the township for the full year's bills.
About these numbers
Payment figures are estimates for illustration only, not a loan offer or a guarantee of terms. They assume roughly a 7.18% 30-year fixed rate (Freddie Mac's average as of November 5, 2026; rates change daily) and the down payments noted; your actual rate, payment, taxes, and insurance will differ based on your lender, your credit, and the assessor's valuation after sale. Tax estimates use the State of Michigan Property Tax Estimator with 2025 millage rates and the most recent SEV on record. Property taxes reset on transfer under Michigan law, and a non-homestead second home is taxed higher than a principal residence. Short-term-rental income is not guaranteed and depends on township, county and state rules. I am a REALTOR, not a lender, attorney, or tax advisor, so please verify all figures with the right professional. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Equal Housing Opportunity.